At first glance, Ottawa’s latest immigration plan looks steady and predictable. Look closer, however, and you’ll find a masterclass in creative accounting that hides the real numbers from Canadians.
In this episode of Classonomics, Sabrina Maddeaux and Mike Moffatt unpack the numbers behind Canada’s latest immigration plan. How do buried “one-time” measures push Ottawa’s target from 380,000 permanent residents to a record-breaking 660,000 next year? And why does the government’s claim that converting temporary residents won’t add pressure to housing or public services ignore basic population math?
They also examine the decision to loosen low-wage temporary foreign worker rules as unemployment hits 6.7%. What would a more transparent, long-term immigration plan look like if it were grounded in actual labour market needs?
Plus, they discuss Andrew Coyne’s take on Canada’s immigration debate and what gets lost when political arguments overshadow the real numbers.
If you enjoy the show and would like to support our work, please consider subscribing to our YouTube channel. The pod is also available on various audio-only platforms, including:
Below is an AI-generated transcript of the Missing Middle podcast, lightly edited.
Sabrina Maddeaux: Last week’s budget came with the new immigration plan, and the headline number was 380,000 new permanent residents a year. Steady. Predictable. Apparently nothing to see here, except that number leaves a lot out.
Mike Moffatt: It turns out the actual number is much higher, thanks to some quote-unquote one-time measures that the government is planning for the second year in a row. RBC estimates that once these measures are accounted for, Canada will admit 660,000 permanent residents next year, an all-time record.
Sabrina Maddeaux: And in the same week, Ottawa loosened the rules for low-wage temporary foreign workers, right as unemployment climbed to 6.7%, and it’s even higher among young workers.
Today, we’re getting into what the plan actually adds up to, why some people insist it doesn’t matter, and what it all means for young Canadians looking for work.
Mike Moffatt: So first off, I need to congratulate you, as your recent column made the front page of the Post. Big congratulations.
Sabrina Maddeaux: Thank you. Although I would argue that the Carney government earned it on my behalf with their deceptive immigration numbers.
Mike Moffatt: So this has to be the first time that an immigration plan has been described as a Jackson Pollock painting. So walk me through your analogy here.
Sabrina Maddeaux: Yeah, I described it that way because of how abstract and confusing—I would say intentionally so—the plan was.
What should have been A plus B equals C, and fairly straightforward math and easy to understand, resulted in mass confusion at first. Even amongst policy experts and economists, like yourself, who were saying, “Wait, what does this really mean? It’s going in all sorts of directions, and the language is very vague here. How do we figure this out?”
So the plan said that 380,000 permanent residents and 370,000 temporary arrivals were going to be the target for the next three years. Then separately, there were also two one-time measures to give permanent residence to up to 200,000 temporary residents by the end of next year.
The problem was that nobody could tell if that 200,000 was inside the quote-unquote overall 380,000 target or on top of it. And again, even economists were confused by this.
The next day, there was a technical briefing, and their officials still wouldn’t give a true total number or even admit one existed. Instead, they talked only about separate targets and one-time measures in different buckets, saying they were in parallel and should be interpreted separately.
So in government speak, it eventually became clear that that extra 200,000 would in fact be on top of the quote-unquote overall target. That doesn’t necessarily mean all.
I think I got that right, Mike. Is it, in fact, on top?
Mike Moffatt: Yeah, you absolutely did.
There’s the target of 380,000, and then there’s a bunch of other things above the target raising the numbers. And the whole thing feels exceptionally deceptive. You think the target is the thing you’re trying to hit, right? But no, it turns out we’re trying to hit something that’s two feet above the target. So it feels very, very deceptive.
And as well, I had a laugh at the framing here. They are framing this as, again, a quote-unquote one-time measure. But the government had two other one-time measures last year, which totalled an additional 148,000 permanent resident spots that were spread over 2026 and into 2027.
So we also have to account for past decisions when trying to figure out what the actual target is, and incorporate those into the numbers. So if you add up all of these one-time measures and add it to the target, you’re now looking at something in the 660,000 range, which is a whole lot more than 380,000.
Sabrina Maddeaux: Yeah. As you said, we’re on our third one-time measure, and the one-time measure from last year is still ongoing and will be added on top of the one-time measures from this year.
Even at the height of the Trudeau years, when immigration was, I think most people agree, unsustainable, permanent resident admissions peaked in the high 400,000s, which is much less than 600,000.
So does anything else jump out at you here?
Mike Moffatt: Yeah, it does.
So when we look at the immigration levels plan, normally they let us know what the plan is. The numbers are for the next two years, but beyond that, they set a high-level vision of how the immigration system is going to work in the longer term. And since late 2024, they’ve set this longer-term vision of keeping permanent residency admissions at or under 1%.
Well, if you take the target they just announced and the multiple one-off commitments, we’re at 1.6%. And you will know that 1.6 is neither at 1% or under 1%.
So not only is this violating their own targets, but it’s also violating the long-term vision that they set for the country that’s supposed to guide hospitals and schools and municipal governments making infrastructure and making plans. But it’s also supposed to guide newcomers who are coming to Canada. They want to know what they’re getting themselves into, but they can’t because we’re changing the rules every 15 seconds. It’s just hard to keep up.
Sabrina Maddeaux: Yeah. Which is how we ended up in this mess to begin with. And then once the real total came out and there was some understandable outrage, the Liberal defence seemed to be basically that the extra measures don’t count. Those extra 200,000 people don’t matter because they are already in the country as temporary residents. At a press conference, Carney said - this is a quote - “…they are in many respects — in all respects — permanent residents of the country and we’re formalizing it.”
So, Mike, is he wrong?
Mike Moffatt: Well, he’s not entirely wrong, but I would say mostly wrong.
It is true that converting someone who already lives here doesn’t add a person to the country on day one—there’s nobody landing at Pearson Airport or what have you. But the thing is, those temporary residents on paper were supposed to leave or become permanent residents through the already existing 380,000 channels like everyone else. So the net effect is still population growth, because you’re reducing the outflow of temporary residents.
RBC found that departures last year came in at roughly half of what was planned. So these one-time conversions, they’re sitting outside of the regular target. Those people don’t leave, but they don’t count against the numbers either.
So it’s really hard to know what’s going on. But the net effect of it is that our population is growing faster than what the government says their plan is for Canada.
Back in 2025, for example, Canada’s non-permanent resident population was supposed to fall by about 440,000 people—and that’s the net effect of inflows versus outflows. Well, instead, it only fell by about 90,000. So the net effect of that is that our population grew by a third of a million more people than planned. And that’s a challenge because when governments don’t plan for growth, they don’t build the schools, the transit, and the hospitals to support it.
I want to make it very clear that I’m not blaming the immigrants or temporary workers for that. And in fact, they’re often the biggest victims of this because they come over and we don’t have the services for them. They end up having to put their kids in overcrowded schools. There aren’t transition supports and so on simply because we haven’t planned for this.
So I want to make it very clear: monkeying around with immigration targets every 15 minutes is not a pro-immigration policy. It’s an anti-immigration policy, because it doesn’t set up the conditions for newcomers to Canada to thrive.
Sabrina Maddeaux: Yeah. And it also doesn’t set up the conditions to maintain Canada’s long-held consensus around immigration. And it is about planning because, by definition, temporary residents aren’t permanent residents. They’re counted separately for a reason. They have different economic roles, different impacts on population, different pressures long term on housing, health care, and infrastructure. To me, it’s like dinner guests turning into roommates and saying there’s no difference between staying for three courses and staying indefinitely.
What I also found convenient was that the federal Liberals have committed to getting the temporary resident population to 5% of the total share of Canada’s population. They’ve already had to extend that goal by a year.
But by just converting temporary residents to permanent residents, that’s very convenient rebranding, since we know that people aren’t leaving as they were expected to, and they don’t have the appetite to actually enforce the law here.
Mike Moffatt: Yeah, it’s too true.
So the government is trying to hit this 5% target, which is somewhere between 2 and 2.5 million people. They’re essentially trying to hit it through an accounting trick. But even with that accounting trick, we’re still not going to be able to hit it. As you point out, it’s already been shifted once from a 2026 deadline to a 2027 deadline.
And it looks like we’ll probably blow past the 2027 deadline with the fact that some folks aren’t leaving, and the fact that the government is doing things like expanding temporary foreign worker programs. So it’s hard to see how we’re going to hit that 5% target even with these accounting tricks.
Sabrina Maddeaux: Right. And before we move on, I do have to bring up an Andrew Coyne column in the Globe and Mail from a couple of weeks back, because it takes the government’s “they’re already here” argument and just runs with it in a way that almost made my brain explode.
The column’s title was “The real immigration fib: Far fewer migrants are entering Canada than official figures say.” Coyne’s case is that a growing share of new permanent residents are former temporary residents already living here—as we talked about, 58% so far this year, per IRCC—so far fewer new arrivals than the headline numbers suggest.
So he makes a claim that the public consensus on immigration hasn’t actually broken, and Canadians remain relatively supportive. He cites Environics numbers that say the share of Canadians saying there’s too much immigration went from 27% in 2022 to a 58% peak in 2024, and it’s 48% now. That same survey found a clear majority saying that there’s too much immigration for the first time in a quarter century.
Clearly, public opinion on immigration has changed over the years. Our pollsters didn’t even poll on it a few years ago, and now it’s a top three issue for a growing share of Canadians. He then goes on to insinuate that critics of these policies are racist, and he mocks how anyone raising concerns rushes to clarify it’s not about immigrants themselves, and pins part of the backlash on online disinformation, where I think the real disinformation here came from the government and the budget itself.
And yeah, it’s true that people who are critical of these policies, including us, aren’t blaming immigrants themselves. Again, we’re talking about planning and the impacts on housing, health care, and often the impacts on immigrants as well.
And then he goes on to undercut his own argument. He says that temporary residents have always made up part of our admissions. They were 21% of it in 2015, 42% in 2025, by his own figures. So that regular 380,000 already counts people who are here. Of course, temporary residents have always been a share of PR admissions. So if conversions were always inside the total, then why does this batch get to sit outside of it?
I’m going to stop ranting for a second and throw it to you for reaction.
Mike Moffatt: Yeah, I found this column stunning. I don’t know if it was on the front page or not. I’m going to have to go check. I certainly hope not.
Yeah, it’s a lot of theatre where he says, in effect, that the numbers are overstated because they don’t account for temporary residents transitioning to permanent residency. But that assumes those temporary residents would otherwise have stayed in Canada as temporary residents.
If that were true, then yeah, the population doesn’t increase. But the government’s own plan was for them to return to their home countries. So there is a net effect, right?
Andrew’s argument is basically: imagine you’re at a restaurant and you’ve been there three, four, or five hours, and the restaurant owner says, “Sorry, you’re going to have to go. This table is reserved.” And you’re saying, “Well, it’s not causing any issues. I’m already here, so how could you possibly be short on tables?” The argument doesn’t recognize that inflows and outflows happen. And if you stop the outflows, you’re going to build up this grand area.
I really have a problem with the fact that he’s right in the sense that there are some people who are quite racist. There are some people who don’t want more immigrants. And when the government lies about this stuff, deceives about this stuff, it makes the worst people in the country right. And I hate that. I absolutely hate that.
So let’s be honest about it. Let’s be upfront about it. Let’s plan, let’s make sure that newcomers to Canada have the conditions where they can thrive. And then we can tell the worst people in the country to go stuff themselves rather than making them into the only people who are telling the truth.
So I think that is my biggest annoyance about all of this, is that we’re making some awful people right. Or they’re at least telling a story that is more accurate than what we’re getting from the government itself.
Sabrina Maddeaux: Right. And lumping anyone critical of our current immigration planning—or lack of it—into this conspiracy theory, racist mob really isn’t helpful at all.
He seems to have this idea that wanting some temporary residents to leave is some sort of hidden agenda, but baked into the word “temporary” is that some should eventually leave; that’s what temporary means.
And the government’s 5% target was built on people departing when that status ends, or a large share of them. And he had this one line that asked, “Can it be that immigration’s alleged harms have only affected Conservative voters?”
Okay, well, first of all, “alleged harms,” and it’s not immigration harms in and of itself. It’s the unplanned surge with a lack of capacity for housing and infrastructure.
Apparently, it's putting employers who prefer to pay low, stagnant wages—their interests over those of the many young Canadians who can’t get a promotion or even a job in many cases. So he’s implying that there’s no real critique here.
I would argue that maybe he’s in the rare demographic where these policies’ harms haven’t affected him because he’s older, a homeowner, and has been gainfully employed for many, many years. And so that, I think, is something that he needs to consider a little bit more.
Mike Moffatt: Yeah. Well, this has real consequences that, again, by the government itself - the government is the one who made the claim that these moves were necessary, the moves a few years ago to reduce the temporary population, that was necessary to achieve other social goals. And so they were either wrong then or wrong now. But you’ve got this case where we’re trying to defend both, or at least some people are trying to defend both.
If you go back to the 2025 Immigration Levels Plan, which was released in late 2024, it had committed to shrinking the population overall by about 200,000 people a year—that Canada’s population would actually decline. And it was explicit in the plan that the reason they wanted to do that was to close the housing supply gap. If you read the plan, it’s bullet point two, bullet point three; they’re one after another.
But instead, Canada’s population in the last 18 months is up by 360,000 people, and we’re not even finished the year yet. So we’re supposed to be down 200,000; we’re up 360,000. So you’ve got a net effect of over half a million.
I think it’s fair to point that out. And I think it’s fair to also point out that the government itself said that we need to get the population down in order to address a housing supply gap.
Well, we haven’t done that. Therefore, we’re not addressing the housing supply gap, or at least in a way that the federal government had planned.
Sabrina Maddeaux: If the critiques seem more concentrated on the Conservative side of the spectrum, I’d say that’s also because a lot of young people are leaning Conservative right now because of housing, cost of living, employment—again, because they’ve borne the brunt of the impacts of these types of policies.
But I’d like to shift back to the week when the budget was released, because the day after the budget, there was another immigration announcement. Ottawa announced on that Friday changes to the Temporary Foreign Worker Program. So Mike, give us a short version of that.
Mike Moffatt: Yeah, absolutely. But I just want to go back to your earlier point that I don’t think it should be a mystery why the opposition is the one who is more opposed to the government.
Sabrina Maddeaux: That too. Yes.
Mike Moffatt: Now we have to have a review of how the Westminster system works, rather than a review of immigration policy. But we’ll leave that for another episode.
Let’s go back to Temporary Foreign Worker policy. There are a couple of big changes here. First, effective right away, employers can get approval to keep a low-wage temporary foreign worker for up to two years instead of one.
So that’s a big benefit to them. And secondly, a proposal was put in place that would go into effect next March: if a province asks, employers in some communities could fill up to 15% of their workforce with low-wage temporary foreign workers, which is up from 10%, which is the current status quo.
So the government is loosening the rules to allow for more low-wage temporary foreign workers in Canada.
Sabrina Maddeaux: Right. And the Jobs Minister said Canadians must always be first in line for available jobs. So she’s saying first in line, but also at the same time doubling how long employers can keep low-wage foreign workers and then also offering to raise the cap by half.
And announced that same day, Statistics Canada said unemployment rose to 6.7%. The government’s own released data that same day still pointed to unemployment falling to 6.5%.
So there’s a gap there, and a two-year approval locks in that assumption of a labour shortage for two years in a job market that’s clearly turning. And a lot of people are struggling, especially younger workers who are often the ones competing with temporary foreign workers.
Mike Moffatt: Yeah, it’s madness.
We can say that Canadians are first in line, but we only do that by eliminating the line and making sure that there are no job vacancies in the first place, because the job vacancies get filled through these Temporary Foreign Worker programs.
So it’s just maddening that we’ve got a situation in Canada where youth unemployment is incredibly high.
Students are having trouble finding summer jobs. They did last year. They had trouble the year before. I’m expecting that to happen again in 2027, just because there’s so much competition for these jobs relative to the number available.
And there’s always going to be a lot of employers who prefer temporary foreign workers and are willing to pay more for temporary foreign workers because, unlike domestic workers, they can’t threaten domestic workers with deportation if they start complaining about job conditions or refusing to take extra shifts or what have you. It’s a real exploitative system and is very, very harmful to younger workers who want to get a foot in the door.
So this is really problematic. And I’m disappointed in the government that is making these programs even more expansive, which just reduces the rights and abilities of younger workers to get a job.
Sabrina Maddeaux: Okay, so what would a plan that actually made sense look like?
Mike Moffatt: So we’re not just going to complain. We’re actually going to throw some solutions on here. So I’ve got a couple of things.
One is: put real totals in the table. If it’s 600,000-plus, if that’s a target, say so. And then that way provinces and cities and homebuilders can plan for it.
I think at one level, Andrew is right about the fact that government isn’t particularly transparent on these temporary-to-permanent flows. Well, put that in the plan as well. Don’t half put it in and half put it out. Be transparent about these figures and ideally have it last longer. The plan itself only lasts two years, but it really doesn’t because you get these one-off things thrown in. So we don’t even hit the targets in the first place.
But even if we were hitting the targets, make those targets last 5 or 10 years, not two, because you can’t build a school, a hospital, or a high-rise apartment in a few months. Things just don’t react that quickly. We need to have long-term planning. And when it comes to the Temporary Foreign Worker Program, I think we’ve got to tie rules to what the job market is actually doing.
I think with unemployment rising, especially for young people, I really don’t understand why the government thinks now is a good time to hire low-wage workers from abroad. And I think in general, the low-wage program probably shouldn’t exist. It’s not the government’s job to keep wages artificially low. If there are shortages in this area, the market should kick in and increase those wages.
So I do think there are times where you do need to bring in temporary foreign workers because they bring a unique skill set that we can’t get here in Canada. But when it’s fast-food restaurants and ice cream places and stuff, if they’re having trouble finding workers, they should be raising their wages, not going, “Okay, well, we’ll just bring in more cheap labour.”
So it just doesn’t make sense.
Sabrina Maddeaux: Yeah. If we’re going to claim to operate in a free-market capitalist society, then there should be competition for labour, right? And then we’ll maybe actually see wages rise in Canada.
To wrap up, these one-time measures are becoming a habit, too. And there really are impacts. A temporary foreign worker becoming a permanent resident does change the impacts on housing, infrastructure, and health care.
It’d be like a business turning all its one-time expenses into recurring ones just because they’re already on the budget sheet. There is clearly going to be sustainability questions coming from the finance department in that scenario. Young Canadians and all Canadians deserve an immigration plan they can read without an accompanying technical briefing that also doesn’t offer any clear answers.
And it’s just this level of accounting that’s creative, to say the least, that really should qualify for the Liberals’ own new artist tax credit.
As I said in my column, I think people elected Carney for, in part, his business and economic sense. And this is a breach of trust and transparency that should not become a habit.
And I think it will eventually catch up with him if that continues.
Mike Moffatt: Yeah. Hear, hear. I couldn’t agree with you more. That this does feel really off-brand for this government to have a program that has these deceptive numbers all over the place. It feels very Jackson Pollock, like you said, that the government is just flicking a paintbrush. So I would love to see the government stick to its own brand and do some long-term planning with KPIs, key performance indicators, and so on to get us to a place we need to be.
Sabrina Maddeaux: Thank you, everyone, for watching and listening. Our producer is Meredith Martin, and our editor is Sean Foreman.
Mike Moffatt: And if you have any thoughts or questions about 20th-century artists, please leave a comment on YouTube or like and subscribe. It would really help us out a lot.
Sabrina Maddeaux: And we’ll see you next time.
Additional Reading/Listening that Helped Inform the Episode:
Sabrina Maddeaux: Carney’s immigration accounting is so creative, it should qualify for the new artist tax break (National Post)
The real immigration ‘fib’? Far fewer migrants are entering Canada than official figures say (The Globe and Mail)
Canadian public opinion about immigration and refugees – Fall 2025 (Environics Institute)
Longer stays, new exemptions in foreign worker overhaul (CTV News)
New Immigration Levels Plan adds upside to population growth outlook (RBC Economics)
Report Of The Bank of Canada on Monetary Policy; Mark Carney, April 23, 2013, 09:25:37
Funded by the Neptis Foundation
Brought to you by the Missing Middle Initiative





