Are young Canadians really choosing “useless” degrees, or is playing it safe the biggest risk of all?
In this episode of DemograFix, Cara Stern and Mike Moffatt dig into why recent university graduates are struggling to find work, even though more students than ever are studying so-called practical fields. They look at why the share of degrees in health sciences, engineering, business and computer science has climbed from 42 percent to more than 60 percent, why the trades aren’t the guaranteed safe bet they’re made out to be, and why funnelling a whole generation into the same handful of majors makes the job market more fragile.
If you enjoy the show and would like to support our work, please consider subscribing to our YouTube channel. The pod is also available on various audio-only platforms, including:
Below is an AI-generated transcript of the Missing Middle podcast, lightly edited.
Cara Stern: When it comes to choosing what to study in university, the message kids tend to get is pretty universal: pick something practical, go into STEM, study something that will lead you to a job, and don’t waste time studying something useless.
Mike Moffatt: And it turns out that most of them listened. Despite this, young graduates are struggling to find work, while outdated stereotypes exist about “useless” degrees.
Cara Stern: So today on DemograFix, we’re asking a question that might sound a little backwards: what if the pressure to play it safe is actually the biggest risk of all?
Mike, this comes from an op-ed you just wrote for the Globe and Mail, so I’m going to get you to start outlining the argument.
Mike Moffatt: Yeah, well, let’s start with how bad the numbers actually are. Unemployment among young people with bachelor’s degrees is at levels we haven’t seen since the early ’90s, excluding the pandemic, of course. Job postings that require one of those bachelor’s degrees have fallen by about 6% over the last year. There are nearly five unemployed people for every opening requiring a degree. And the length of time young people stay unemployed has nearly doubled since 2023. It’s really bad out there for young graduates.
Cara Stern: Yeah, I would not want to be a young graduate entering this market. And usually I hear people chalk it up to people studying useless degrees, like earlier this year, when Doug Ford famously told students, “Well, you’re picking basket-weaving courses, and there’s not too many baskets being sold out there.”
Mike Moffatt: Yeah, it’s really funny how generations can blame other generations for the things that their own generations did. My favourite example of this is how boomers like making fun of millennials’ participation trophies. And like any good Gen Xer, I enjoy a good millennial joke as much as anyone. But when it comes to those participation trophies, that’s not on you guys, that’s on the boomers. Millennials didn’t ask for that. Boomers came up with the idea of participation trophies and handed them out to millennials in the 1990s like they were juice boxes and orange slices at peewee soccer games, right? So that’s on them, not on you guys.
And I think the same thing’s happening here, where Gen Z is getting stuck with this stereotype around useless courses or frivolous degrees. But if anything, the data suggests that stereotype should be more associated with boomers and Gen Xers than with Gen Z.
Cara Stern: Yeah, that really did surprise me in your Globe piece: since the early ’90s, the share of university bachelor’s degrees in what we think of as the practical fields, like health sciences, engineering, business and computer science, went from 42% to more than 60%. So that really goes against the narrative that kids are just choosing the wrong degrees.
Mike Moffatt: Yeah, it really does. Students are increasingly entering a handful of majors that they’ve been told all their lives are “safe or practical”. But as it turns out, when an entire generation of young people tries to enter the same handful of professions, you lose a lot of diversity there.
And that lack of diversity makes our labour market less stable, right? Because everybody’s putting their eggs in the same basket. So we’ve gotten to a point now where, ironically, excessive safety is becoming a bit of a vice and making the whole system less safe.
Cara Stern: It makes me wonder whether going to university is really their best choice, because you hear a lot about how the trades are a better place for people to be, that maybe too many people are going to university, and if you want to find a job and start earning earlier on, the trades are where you should go.
Mike Moffatt: Yeah, and there’s certainly logic to that. And obviously there are a lot of great opportunities and money to be made in the trades. As the son of a sheet metal mechanic and a high school shop teacher, I grew up around the trades. But this idea that simply starting a trades education is a safe choice is absolutely a myth. Apprenticeship completion rates are alarmingly low. In many areas, they tend to be less than 50%.
So a young person looking at these options and trying to figure out which is the safer bet kind of goes, “Okay, yeah, I can study to become a welder, but if only a third or 40 or 45% of people actually end up in that profession, I don’t necessarily like those odds. Maybe I’d be better off going to university.”
Cara Stern: It is kind of weird how it feels like we’re sometimes blaming students for making the wrong choice. And I just keep reminding myself, they’re teenagers. I don’t know how much credit we should be giving them for what they’re picking. Of course, you want people to be picking the direction they’re going, but I suspect a lot of them are taking advice from adults. That’s a tall ask for a teenager, to be able to predict what the job market is going to be like four years from now when they get out, and even longer, right?
Mike Moffatt: Yeah, it really is. We ask teenagers a lot, and to be fair, that was the case for you and for me and for other generations, and certainly people do make suboptimal choices. I think that’s fair, right?
But when it becomes this idea that an entire generation is making bad choices, that’s when I push back a little bit. And I think the bigger issue here is that the cost right now of making the “wrong” choice is really high.
If we think about what those costs are, if you pick a major that doesn’t pan out, you might spend years unemployed or underemployed. In a lot of the country, if you don’t start earning decent money right away, homeownership’s probably not going to happen for you. And all of those milestones we think of, homeownership, having children, that kind of thing, if you’re not earning enough and fast enough, you get locked out.
So of course students are going to play it safe. Nobody can afford to explore. This idea that we’ve got this generation who’s out there just making random choices, that’s not where the incentives are. The incentives are to make the safe choice. And most of them are.
Cara Stern: It always does come back to housing, eh? When I think about it, I guess this wouldn’t be as big of an issue if housing wasn’t so expensive. Then people could maybe afford to take risks in a way that they just can’t. There’s just no room for error.
Mike Moffatt: That’s exactly it. And to be clear, this kind of risk aversion and focus on playing it safe starts way before university. It used to be that a 96% average would guarantee you a spot in any program at any university in Canada, and it just doesn’t anymore. You see these articles about some kid who applies with a 97 or 98% average to get into some engineering program, and they get turned down. It’s just bananas.
I’ll be honest with you here. No university in Ontario today would take a chance on someone with the high school transcript that I had 30 years ago. And I’d like to think I’ve had a fairly successful career.
It’s a little bit bonkers to think that this guy, who is a university professor and has spent most of his life in higher ed, probably wouldn’t even get in today at 18 years old with his grades.
Cara Stern: How bad was it?
Mike Moffatt: Well, they used to call my report card The Hive, because it was full of bees.
Cara Stern: That was bad. I know I was the student taking the courses that I knew I could do well at. It was drilled into my head from the time I was young that academic success was really important. And when I look back, I kind of wish I had learned that learning itself was more important than good grades.
I still have this disagreement with my mom. She still insists that that’s the right move. And part of it has to do with universities tying scholarships to grades, so it’s not only about getting in. In university, I had an entrance scholarship that would renew every year if my grades were high enough. And so that limited what I could take, because if I didn’t know that I would succeed, that was risky.
I was actually betting money on the result. I wish I’d had the leeway to take what I wanted just out of pure interest, but there wasn’t room to do that.
Mike Moffatt: Yeah, that’s exactly right. And I think that’s important here, because we’ll probably get comments from people saying, “Well, it was like that when I went to school.” And that’s true to a certain extent. This has always been a pressure, trying to design what courses you take in high school or university to stay above a certain grade threshold. I think what’s changed is just a matter of degree. It’s gotten a whole lot worse now. And because it’s a whole lot worse now, it’s really forcing students to make these safe choices, which limits their growth and makes them one-dimensional.
Take jobs with the federal government. A lot of those require you to be bilingual. If you’re a student and you go, “Ah, I don’t know if I would do well in French,” you’re probably not going to take French, but then that might lock you out of some of those public service jobs, right? You’re still making the safe choice.
And again, to take it back to my personal experience, the most valuable skills I use to this day I got in university courses like philosophy and applied mathematics that were out of my comfort zone. Some of them I did quite well in, and others I bombed. But I still learned a lot, even if my transcript didn’t look fantastic. The incentives back then were different, or at least there wasn’t as much of a penalty for failure.
Cara Stern: Philosophy is the one that you felt made the biggest impact on your life, and it wasn’t part of your degree. It was something you took just because you were interested. What is it about it that you feel speaks to what you do today?
Mike Moffatt: Well, I think a lot of it is just how to think about problems, how to define problems, how to develop an argument, but also how to see the flaws in your own arguments. And to be clear, I actually did really well in philosophy, but I didn’t know I would. It was kind of a leap of faith.
So yeah, it’s the kind of skills I use every day. My double major was in economics and political science, and those intricacies of Canadian constitutional law, if I’m arguing with somebody on Twitter, yeah, that might not come up. But even then, I’m probably using the skills I learned in the philosophy course more than anything else to do that. And again, the only reason I was able to take those courses is that I knew, okay, even if I don’t get a good grade in that, I’m going to be okay. So why not explore my interests?
Cara Stern: I liked an analogy you used in the article, where you described it as going to the gym and only doing exercises you’re good at, with weights light enough that you’ll never fail.
Mike Moffatt: The analogy I use here is, imagine we created a system where every day you were assessed on your ability to do 12 reps of a weightlifting exercise with good form. And because I’m a nice guy, you can choose the weight, and you can choose whatever exercise you like. That’s up to you. But the only thing I’m going to assess you on is your ability to do 12 clean reps. Well, if you’re a student in my bizarre weightlifting school, what are you going to do?
Cara Stern: Obviously pick an exercise I already knew I could handle, at a weight that was easy enough that I knew I would nail it.
Mike Moffatt: Yeah, exactly. And if you’re trying to maximize your grade, that’s the correct choice.
Cara Stern: Right.
Mike Moffatt: That’s where all the incentives are. That’s what everybody’s going to do. But if you’re trying to actually get into functional shape, which is what I think you would want to be doing in this kind of weightlifting school, that’s a terrible way to do it, because strength gains happen through progressive overload. Adaptation stops if you keep lifting the same amount of weight the same way. And if you’re just doing one exercise over and over, you’re going to develop really bad muscular imbalances. You’re going to have people with massive Popeye arms and little stick legs.
And that’s what, in my view, our system is doing today.
It’s basically creating a generation of kids that are skipping the educational equivalent of leg day, because they’re so hyper-focused on doing one thing that they know they can do well.
Cara Stern: And going back to the problem here, we’re advising students to pick safe things, but adults tend to be pretty terrible at predicting what the safe majors are. We can see that from what they’ve been recommending over the last 10 years or so, and from how industries have adapted to things like AI. No one really knows what the safe bet is.
Mike Moffatt: Yeah, and that’s a real tragedy in all of this. Nobody is intentionally trying to set young people up to fail. We’re all well-meaning parents and teachers and guidance counsellors. But our track record here is awful. What we keep advising folks, helping them find the right degree, is essentially funnelling a growing share of students into three or four or five programs, like business consulting and computer science.
That share has increased over time, but it’s not all that new. If you go back to the Obama administration, he was encouraging everyone to learn to code. I remember that was such a huge thing 10 or 15 years ago, and a lot of people took that advice seriously. But look at it today. You mentioned AI. The fields that are most exposed to AI are things like computer science and business consulting. So those jobs, which were “safe”, weren’t safe at all.
Cara Stern: There is still some demand, but it’s nothing like it was before. I know so many people who switched careers by taking a boot camp course kind of thing, and they were able to shift into it. And that isn’t working anymore, especially at the lower tier of entry-level positions. They don’t need it so much anymore.
I don’t know if it’s changing faster, but it does feel like right now fields that seem safe are so at risk, because we just don’t know where AI is going to land. It’s such a huge disruption to our working lives.
Mike Moffatt: We still need coders. We still need business consultants and things like that. But we’ve massively increased the number of folks that we teach those skills at a time when the prediction was that demand was going to go up. In fact, if anything, it’s probably gone down, particularly, as you point out, at the entry level. The future is always uncertain, but it feels more uncertain now than it might have a generation ago.
Cara Stern: It’s like we’re investing our kids’ futures in maybe one or two stocks. I know no financial advisor would ever recommend that as a strategy, even though we all do it with our houses. No one would say that’s a good idea. So I wonder how we go about trying to fix it and diversify, so there’s a bigger variety in what people are trying to get into.
Mike Moffatt: I think the problem is ultimately culture, not policy. The culture needs to change. The first thing I think we have to do is bust this myth that the struggles young people are facing in the job market are because they’re taking frivolous majors, right? We’re never going to solve a problem if we don’t understand what the root issues are, particularly if we’re getting it 100% wrong and think that there aren’t enough young people doing the safe educational thing, when in fact it’s probably the opposite that’s true.
I think the other thing, and this is a really meta point that goes well beyond education, is that for young people in particular, we’ve created this culture where failure is not an option. That sounds tough, but to ensure failure isn’t an option, we’ve coated everything in bubble wrap.
We’ve created a couple of generations of young people who aren’t allowed to fail and are understandably terrified of taking any kind of risk.
One of the influencers that I really like, Gary Vaynerchuk, talks about this all the time, and I think he’s right. Young people need to take more risks, and older people like me should be giving them a helping hand and encouraging them to take the next risk. I think that would go a long way.
Cara Stern: Yeah, it’s really rational for millennials to be too scared to take those kinds of risks, because life is just so expensive. You can’t take the time off to go back to school when you’re paying such exorbitant rents or mortgages. And if you take time off at some point early on, you might lock yourself out of homeownership forever, because you won’t ever make up the money you lost.
So I guess politicians and parents should probably realize that none of us know what’s going to be safe in the age of AI, and our track record for guesses hasn’t really worked out. So we should be humble about the advice we’re giving to young people.
Mike Moffatt: I think we should be less judgmental of younger people when they make a choice that seems a little unusual. I think we should give them a little bit more permission to explore, even if their interest leads them to basket weaving or what Florida Governor Ron DeSantis calls zombie studies. And if that path ends up being a dead end, that’s okay. Help them steer on to a different one.
Cara Stern: I hope zombie studies doesn’t become a practical degree anytime soon. But I guess the point is that those degrees can still teach people very useful skills that will come in handy, even if we don’t enter a zombie apocalypse.
Thanks, everyone, for watching and listening. Our producer is Meredith Martin, and this episode was edited by Canadian Civil.
Mike Moffatt: Now, if you have any thoughts or questions on how not to design a weightlifting program, leave a comment on the YouTube video. And while you’re there, like and subscribe.
Cara Stern: And we’ll see you next time.
Additional Reading/Listening that Helped Inform the Episode:
Ford tells students to not pick ‘basket-weaving courses’ in wake of OSAP cuts
Pushed to pursue safe degrees, students are shunning the humanities. At what cost?
DeSantis is taking aim at ‘zombie studies’ on the campaign trail. It’s a real thing



